Resource Logo
Associated Press

Judge Rules for HIV Patient in Transplant


PITTSBURGH - An HIV-positive man in need of a liver transplant was wrongly denied coverage under the state's Medicaid program, an administrative law judge ruled.

William Jean Gough's liver is deteriorating because of hepatitis C. The 46-year-old was accepted as a strong candidate for the lifesaving operation in August by Pittsburgh's Thomas E. Starzl Transplant Institute.

The state Department of Public Welfare, which oversees the state's Medicaid program, denied coverage for Gough, saying that infection with the AIDS virus is a life-limiting condition that rules out a transplant.

In a ruling made public Wednesday, Judge Bernadene Kennedy dismissed the state's argument, saying that scientific advances allow people with HIV to live full lives.

Gough "could live 10, 20, 30 years or more with a liver transplant," Kennedy wrote. "Given his ability to successfully control his HIV, the appellant may live a prolonged life and maintain quality of life equivalent to non-HIV transplant patients."

The judge expedited the case because Gough's condition worsens by the day and he could be ineligible for a transplant if his liver deteriorates too much.

Doctors said the Altoona man could die in nine to 12 months without a transplant. The average wait is six to 12 months.

"I've struggled with this disease for many years and you've got to have hope," Gough said Wednesday. "I just think it's a lack of education in our health care system. It seems to me the state's working off of old criteria."

The Department of Public Welfare will not appeal the judge's ruling, spokeswoman Stephanie Suran said.

It is the second time in two months that Lambda Legal, a gay legal rights group, has successfully argued that patients with HIV should not be excluded from transplants just because they are HIV-positive.

In October, Kaiser Permanente, one of the nation's largest health maintenance organizations, approved a kidney transplant for an HIV-positive man in Denver, reversing an earlier decision. The HMO initially refused John Carl's request for a new kidney, saying a transplant on someone with the AIDS virus is too risky because drugs used to prevent rejection of a new organ can jeopardize their already weakened immune systems.

--- One the Net:

Lambda Legal:


Copyright © 2003 -Associated Press, Publisher. All rights reserved to Associated Press. Reproduction of this article (other than one copy for personal reference) must be cleared through the AP Permissions Desk.

Information in this article was accurate in December 10, 2003. The state of the art may have changed since the publication date. This material is designed to support, not replace, the relationship that exists between you and your doctor. Always discuss treatment options with a doctor who specializes in treating HIV.