Pediatr Radiol. 1997 Nov;27(11):880-7. Unique Identifier : AIDSLINE
BACKGROUND: Multicenter studies rely on data derived from different
institutions. Forms can be designed to standardize the reporting process
allowing reliable comparison of data. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of the
report is to provide a standardized method, developed as a part of a
multicenter study of vertically transmitted HIV, for assessing chest
radiographic results. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Eight hundred and five
infants and children were studied at five centers; 3057 chest
radiographs were scored. Data were entered using a forced-choice, graded
response for 12 findings. Quality assurance measures and inter-rater
agreement statistics are reported. RESULTS: The form used for reporting
chest radiographic results is presented. Inter-rater agreement was
moderate to high for most findings, with the best correlation reported
for the presence of bronchovascular markings and/or reticular densities
addressed as a composite question (kappa = 0.71). The presence of
nodular densities (kappa = 0.56) and parenchymal consolidation (kappa =
0.57) had moderate agreement. Agreement for lung volume was low.
CONCLUSION: The current tool, developed for use in the pediatric
population, is applicable to any study involving the assessment of
pediatric chest radiographs for a large population, whether at one or
many centers.
*Quality Assurance, Health Care *Radiography, Thoracic/STANDARDS
www.aegis.org